Pie Guys' Pizza and more

Courtney Thompson 9 months ago

Pizza was Amazing wish i had tried them sooner. Cant wait to explore more of the menu which is vast. Just found one of local go to spots.

Casey Patterson 2 years ago

Love the pizza here. I always get the bbq cheese burger minus the meat since I’m vegetarian and it hits every time. The sauce they include for some reason just tastes amazing with the pizza and I can’t explain it. I’ve also had deserts from here and everything I’ve had I can’t say anything but great things about. Great spot.

Casey Smith 2 years ago

Let all you do be done for Pizza! -Cheese 24/7! "Forget everything you think you know about Winston-Salem pizza! My recent visit to Pie Guys completely redefined this city's white pie pizza for me. The moment I took a bite, it was like a flavor explosion in my mouth. The tomatoes were bursting with juice and the spinach was marinated so well into the cheese you might accidentally forget you hate spinach. The crust was perfectly crispy and airy, yet held everything together beautifully. The toppings were incredibly fresh and bursting with flavor. But it wasn't just the individual components; it was the way everything came together in perfect harmony like the Backstreet Boys in the 90's! It was an experience that transcended mere pizza; it was a culinary masterpiece in a little nook and cranny that makes you feel like your eating a forest. If you're looking for a pizza that will change your perspective on this classic food, Pie Guys is a must-try! You won't be disappointed." Also try the cinnamon knots and cheese sticks you can taste an authentic and organic taste that is not matched anywhere else in Winston-Salem!

Alan Warman 3 years ago

I was visiting the area and was looking for a local pizza place. I am glad I stumbled on this small family owned shop. The pizza was cheesy and delicious. The garlic bread was the best I have had. The crust was thin in the middle and fluffy on the edge with a very well balanced sauce. There is also this honey cream dip that is for the crust and that is the cherry on top. Joseph was a great server from the beginning and made great recommendations. I am only in town a couple days but I will be back.

Lisa H-P Edited 4 years ago

I have been a regular customer here for years, and we ate at Pie Guys a couple of times a month at least. Sometimes once a week. The cashiers knew us by name. I am very sad to say that the new ownership/management have made sure we will never eat there again. We placed an online order for 2 subs and a personal sized pizza. Arrived at the store 20 minutes later expecting to wait for a few minutes. I waited for over an HOUR in the restaurant while they filled orders that came in after mine. All sorts of excuses. I was told "your pizza is next" about 6 times. The manager argued with me that the other customers had put their orders in online as though I was a walk-in, and spoke to me like I was inconveniencing him. This was after another employee had already acknowledged my online order, but claimed it came in 20 minutes later than it was actually placed. Total chaos. After demanding my money back they finally gave me my order. I got home with cold food that had obviously been sitting around in the back somewhere. The subs were HALF a sandwich at best. Not what they used to be when I'd ordered them in the past. The food tasted good, but it wasn't worth the hassle. Not a single employee